The Voice in Your Head That Sounds Like Them

Social media doesn’t facilitate exploration. You find a topic which interests you, swipe and then see 10 AI videos with fruit. 

heywa rewards curiosity. Ask it a question about Stonehenge and it will build you a visual story curated for your learning style. Want to go deeper on one angle? Here’s a new story about the Druids. Curious about something similar? A story about the winter solstice. And there’s no need to reprompt. 

heywa is designed to send you down knowledge rabbit holes without diverting your attention into twenty different directions. 

Try heywa for free

There's a voice in your head that sounds like them.

If you're estranged from somebody who used to know you well, you know exactly the voice I'm talking about. The kid who isn't speaking to you. The ex. The parent you haven't talked to in years. The friend you fell out with.

That voice never went away when they did. It moved in. It runs commentary on your life from inside your own head.

You make a choice and the voice has something to say about it. You buy something and the voice judges the purchase. You take a job and the voice has an opinion. You date somebody and the voice rates them. You post something on social media and the voice critiques the post before you even hit send.

The voice isn't actually them. The voice is your version of them, built from years of knowing them, and now living in your head rent-free, narrating your life as if they were still around to weigh in.

Today's piece is about that voice. What it's doing. What it costs. And how to know when it's running you.

WHERE THE VOICE COMES FROM

The voice didn't show up the day they stopped talking to you. The voice has always been there.

When you live with somebody long enough, you internalize their judgment. You start to know what they would think before they think it. You start to make choices with their reaction already in mind. While the relationship is intact, that internalized voice is just part of the partnership.

Every long relationship installs a copy of the other person inside your head. The copy doesn't get uninstalled when the relationship ends.

When the relationship ends, the real person leaves. The copy stays. The voice is frozen in the moment things broke. It judges your today with the eyes they had at the worst part of your story. And because they aren't around to be a real person anymore, the voice has the floor uncontested.

That's the trap.

WHAT THE VOICE DOES TO YOU

The voice does three things, and all three are bad for you.

It makes you smaller.

The voice's job is to remind you, constantly, of who you were when things were at their worst. It anchors your identity to the version of you that produced the rupture. Anything you try to do that contradicts that version of you, the voice has a comeback for.

You try to start something new and the voice says, who do you think you are. You try to take pride in a win and the voice says, this is just another performance. You try to enjoy a quiet Sunday and the voice says, you don't deserve this, look at what you cost people.

The voice is the worst possible version of them, weaponized against the version of you that's trying to grow.

It doesn't reflect what they actually think today. It reflects what they thought on the day everything broke. They might have moved on. They might have softened. They might think about you with more nuance than they did then. The voice doesn't know any of that. The voice is a frozen snapshot. And it keeps you small.

It makes you perform.

Sometimes the voice doesn't tear you down. Sometimes it pushes you to perform.

You make a choice and you can feel the voice approving or disapproving. You decide what to wear, where to go, what car to drive, what to post, with the voice running a constant assessment. Would they think this is good. Would they think I've changed. Would they think I'm doing better.

If they ever see this photo. If they ever drive by this house. If they ever hear about this trip. If they ever Google my company.

Performing for somebody who isn't watching is the most expensive thing you can do with your life.

You spend years curating a life designed to be seen by someone who isn't looking. The whole performance is for an audience of one, and the audience of one has the channel turned off.

It steals your present.

The voice keeps you out of the room you're actually in.

You're at dinner with somebody who loves you and the voice is in your ear. You're at a quiet morning with the dog and the voice is in your ear. You're laughing at something and the voice cuts in to remind you that joy isn't free for somebody like you.

If you're always being narrated, you're never really in your own life.

HOW TO KNOW WHEN THE VOICE IS RUNNING YOU

Three tells.

Tell one. You make a decision and your first internal review of it sounds like them. Not your voice. Their voice. You hear their tone before you hear your own.

Tell two. You're feeling something good and the second feeling that arrives is shame. Joy lands and then guilt lands, almost on top of it. That gap between the two feelings is where the voice lives.

Tell three. You catch yourself rehearsing arguments with them. In the shower. On a drive. Walking the dog. You're explaining yourself to a person who isn't asking for an explanation. The voice has set up a courtroom in your head and you're the one on trial every day.

If any of those sound familiar, the voice is running you. Probably for longer than you realized.

HOW TO TURN THE VOLUME DOWN

You don't get to delete the voice. The copy doesn't get uninstalled. They lived in you for years. That doesn't undo on a schedule.

What you can do is turn the volume down. Three moves.

Move one. Name it.

Out loud. To yourself. When the voice shows up, name it. Say, that's not me. That's the version of them I built. They're not actually in the room.

Naming it doesn't make it leave. Naming it takes the authority away. The voice loses power the moment you stop mistaking it for the truth.

Move two. Update the copy.

If you have to keep a version of them in your head, update the version. Make it the most generous version, not the harshest one. Imagine the version of them that's had two years to soften. The version that's had their own growth. The version that might be capable of grace they couldn't access at the moment of rupture.

You have no way of knowing what the real version of them is today. You're free to choose which version you carry. Most people pick the harshest version because that one feels safer. It hurts in a familiar way. The generous version is more painful at first because it opens you to grief. It's also more accurate, on average, than the worst-case snapshot.

The version of them you choose to carry is a choice. Pick the one that lets you live.

Move three. Build your own voice.

The voice in your head got loud because your own voice went quiet. The work isn't to silence them. The work is to grow your own voice until theirs isn't the dominant one anymore.

Your own voice is built through saying what you actually think. Out loud. In writing. In conversation. With a therapist. With a friend. With this newsletter, frankly. Every time you say what you actually think, instead of what you think they'd approve of, you build a little more of your own voice.

After a few years of that, your voice is louder than theirs. The voice doesn't leave. It just stops being the loudest one.

WHERE THIS LEAVES US TODAY

If the voice in your head sounds like somebody who isn't currently in your life, you're not alone.

Most people who've lost important relationships are walking around with a tenant in their head they didn't invite and can't evict. The tenant judges everything. The tenant has the worst possible take on every move. The tenant is the prosecutor in a trial you didn't agree to participate in.

You don't have to evict the tenant. You just have to stop letting them run the place.

Name them. Update the copy. Build your own voice.

Then walk into your own life like you live there. Because you do.

THIS WEEK I'M THINKING ABOUT

You Cannot Outwork an Identity You Don't Believe In.

If the voice in your head is the loudest voice you hear, your identity isn't yours. It's their leftover assessment of you, dressed up as self-talk.

You can't outwork that. You can grind for a decade and the voice will still be running commentary, because the voice doesn't care about the work. The voice cares about who you secretly believe you are. And as long as you secretly believe you are the version of yourself they last saw, the work won't move the dial.

The identity work isn't to convince the voice you've changed. The voice won't be convinced. The voice doesn't update.

The identity work is to slowly, deliberately, build a separate version of you that isn't living for the voice. That version doesn't need the voice's approval. That version doesn't argue with the voice. That version just exists, gets up in the morning, does the work, lives the day, and goes to bed.

Eventually that version is loud enough that you can't hear the voice over your own breathing.

ONE THING TO TRY THIS WEEK

The next time you make a choice and you can feel the voice weighing in, do this.

Stop. Out loud, say: that's not me. That's the version of them I built.

Then ask yourself a different question. Not, would they approve. Ask: do I.

Make the choice based on the second question. Then notice how it feels in your body to make a choice for yourself instead of for the voice.

That feeling is your own voice waking up. Practice that feeling.

READER QUESTION

Whose voice is the loudest one in your head right now, and what's one decision you made this week that was secretly made for them?

Reply to this email and send it in. I read every one. This one is going to land for a lot of us.

Monday's episode: To be revealed Sunday night.

Dan Kaufman | Grace Over Guilt

Grace Over Guilt  |  Becoming Undone to Become Whole

Ready to transform artificial intelligence from a buzzword into your personal revenue generator

HubSpot’s groundbreaking guide "200+ AI-Powered Income Ideas" is your gateway to financial innovation in the digital age.

Inside you'll discover:

Download your guide today and unlock a future where artificial intelligence powers your success. Your next income stream is waiting.

Get Your Guide